We are no amateurs to pizza eating...having eaten a lot in our lives...and the pizza here ranks up with the best. Excellent crust, interesting choices of toppings. Highly recommend!
1 - 10 of 72 reviews
After an earlier disappointment in Ogunquit, thrilled to find Y54 on way home, by mistake. Food and atmosphere so fun and yummy. Textures and ingredients of food unusually tasty. Will definitely return when come back to Maine.
3 of us went for lunch 10/1/17 and had pizza. It was an excellent choice and it was delicious. Other meals are available and reasonable priced. We shared a medium size pizza and it was more than enough for the 3 of us. There were...More
My wife and I were looking for dinner near our Hotel and It was late. We drove by one restaurant and stumbled into Pizza 54. It was the best mistake we could have made. We walk in and sat down but we didn't realize they...More
Checked reviews for this place and took a chance. WELL! They make some of the tastiest pizza we've ever had. I had hoped it was edible and was very happy with the outcome. The ambiance wasn't what we were looking for and that's good because...More
Very tasty pizza, interesting toppings. Very little ambience. Can be noisy and crowded. Service was fine.
The pizza here is delicious. Kids can get a one topping 8" pizza for 4.99. How can you beat that? We ordered a custom pizza with tomatoes and kalamata olives and it was so freakin' good. Everything is fresh. Service is good. The only gripe...More
We found York 54 through someone that was doing a craft fair with us! This happy accident was one of our best finds. The place is small, and you may have to wait, but it is so worth it! The owner is one of the...More