Reservations are tough to get in season for a good reason - the food and service are excellent! We started with the beets which had a unique flavor and freshness. The halibut entree with shiitake mushrooms and gooseberries set a new standard for us. The...More

This place is simply awesome. Great vibe, wonderful food and top notch service !!!! Can't wait to go back.

I understand that we're eating on MV in Chilmark and so we should expect high prices but OMG were the prices high. Steak was $50 and that didn't include sides. It's BYOB (they have mocktails and you just need to provide the hard stuff) and...More

We had a big group that included two toddlers. We called in the early afternoon and they worked with us to squeeze us in. The service was personal and attentive. The food was outstanding and there was good food for everyone. They also let us...More

Lowered this one star since our last visit - good solid dining options, but not exceptional. We shared a lovely local salad to start with, and my husband had the halibut, which he enjoyed. I had the only vegetarian option - curried cauliflower with wild...More

I'd noticed the tavern from my perch at the Grocery store and was excited to try the place. It's not easy to get a reservation, but we lucked into one and had a fabulous meal. Everything is fresh and beautifully prepared -- even the burgers...More

We had a reservation so had no problem getting a table. The service was professional and friendly and the food, good. The people watching was excellent but don't gawk. We saw Ted Danson and Mary Steenburgen (they're married), and then Tony Shaloub stopped by their...More

This is always a stop for us when we are on MV. This year did not disappoint. The fluke entree was one of the best meals i have had in a long time. My husband got the scallops and they were also delicious. It is...More

We enjoyed this restaurant last summer on a number of occasions. This summer, the cost of meals is sky high and the quality is nowhere near what it was last year. There is a corkage fee because of the BYOB and we completely support that....More

Chilmark Tavern is an up-island restaurant with a well-deserved reputation for good food and service in a casual but professional setting. Up-islanders are fortunate to have this local resource. Really good food and attentive, personal service. A little noisy.