Good atmosphere, plenty of seating. The menu had a wide selection but the pizza I ordered was just average. Could have been what I ordered. I would give them another shot.
1 - 10 of 32 reviews
Well known for the thick crust pizza (thin also available). From bottom to top; crust, cheese, toppings, and then a layer of sauce. Generous toppings. Great crispy edges and tasty albeit a bit sweet sauce. Other dishes at the table also received good reviews. The...More
If I had my choice for the best pizza around I would definitely choose Buddy's. I believe this is about the third or fourth time I've eaten at Shields and twice they got my order wrong. While we were sitting there I could hear people...More
My daughter and I came later 7:30pm on a weeknight and there were not many patrons. We ordered buffalo chicken pizza and an antipasto salad. The pizza was not very good - the sauce was too sweet. The salad was ok. The service was poor;...More
If you're looking for a great deep-dish square pizza, this is the place! It's always fresh & served hot. Sometimes it gets a little busy and the wait for the food a little long, but always worth the wait. Atmosphere can be a little noisy.