The ice cream is a delicious old school hard ice cream. The flavours are endless and newer. The service is fast but the line is crazy long. Plan for an hour or more on a nice day.
1 - 10 of 227 reviews
Lines out the door and around the building. All for average ice cream you can buy at any local grocer. And yet people ask us directions to the place throughout the summer. If they made their own ice cream maybe, but they don’t. Just don’t...More
A favorite local place for delicious ice cream. It's a must visit place for locals and visitors to Stillwater alike! In the summer months, be prepared to stand in line! It's worth the wait.
Consistently the best ice cream, biggest cones (order the "child" size, really), and best value in Stillwater. Worth the drive, worth the wait in line. Cash only. Ask for a cup, too.
You will get a huge double scoop in a jr. size cone ,What a deal,go for it! They have over 20 flavor's of ice cream ,great malts and Sunday's>
Every spring we locals look forward to Nelson's opening. So many flavors of ice cream and such a good value. If it is a hot day, prepare to stand in line.
When you buy ice cream at most places you always feel a little ripped off! Ice cream isn't gold and when you buy ice cream at Nelsons you never EVER feel anything but delicious ice cream going down your throat. They give you more than...More