The slices are big but not much crust, sauce or cheese. It's good enough but $3.75 isn't cheap for a slice of pizza.
1 - 10 of 74 reviews
The mushroom slice of pizza was large but nothing to rave about. Just an ordinary slice of pizza with a price tag that matched. Service was quick though considering how busy they were.
The people working behind the counter were very nice and when we asked for a rag to wipe the outside table off the lady working came out right away to clean it even though we said we would do it. she was not having that....More
I know it is a pizza place and the pizza is pretty good for the island, but the fries are awesome and a must for our family. We own close by and spend our summers in LBI. Whenever we are grilling up burgers or/and hot...More
I have been going to Beach Haven with my family and eating Bay Village Pizza since I was a small child and to this day, it's still the best pizza I have ever had! It's true NY style (obviously), meaning that the slices are the...More
The pizza is not great. It's not even above average. But this place is located just across the street from Thundering Surf water park, so it's extremely convenient. There are better places to have pizza, but people seem to like it!
They serve huge reheated slices of pizza, with limited options. I know it's reheated because there were about 20 pizzas pre-made and sitting on racks by the cook. The cost is above average, I imagine it's due to the high cost of being in bay...More
When we get to LBI, this is the place we stop for lunch during the season. To me this is the best pizza on the island. Great for lunch and dinner pizza. Love this place and wish I can take one pie home for dinner...More
This is my favorite place to for pizza hands down until last night! I do t know what was going on. I order a veggie pie and they had no mushrooms only pepper and onion they said. They didn't have pineapple Or ham for a...More
HUGE (like a double sized) piece of pie... NY STYLE... very good!!! Great French fries too! We hit it up after Fantasy Island. They have picnic seating outside under a covered pavilion.