Been stopping in off and on for years and years. The food is never terrible, never great, and typically inconsistent. Drive in any direction and the next unremarkable pizzeria you find will be exactly the same...
Some of our friends swear by this place, so we decided to give them a try. We ordered a meatball and onion pizza. Well, it wasn't good. The meatballs were bland and dry. The onions were mushy. Just not a very good pizza. Service was...More
The pizza is made by authentic Italian family -- and we originally come from north Jersey -- familiar with really good pizza. Nicola's is hands down better than the 2 neighboring pizzerias. Also, Nicola's has fabulous chicken wings -- crunchy on the outside, tender on...More
New owner Pasquale is terrific! Food is very good and reasonable. Always fresh ingredients. Pizza and Pasta is best in Califon!
Great pizza - order veggie everything (mushrooms, peppers, onion, garlic, tomatoes, etc.) & it was wonderful - really hit the spot!
A charming place where all the locals stop by. The staff is very friendly-- we went 3 nights in a row-- The dinners and salads are excellent-- HUGE portions!