We came here before a show at Cape May Stage My crab cakes were OKAY Wife's fish with mango sauce was tasty
1 - 10 of 500 reviews
The Oyster Bay is one of my favorite restaurants in town, The Veal San Marco being my favorite. The bar area is comfortable and has a bar menu. But the absolute best is their signature dessert- a cheesecake topped with bananas foster. This is no...More
I had the opportunity to take my parents out for a belated mother's day dinner at Oyster Bay. I had heard it was good but maybe expensive. It was excellent and it wasn't that expensive. It was worth every penny.
My wife and I went for dinner in the main dining room and that was good, but the real treat was when we returned one night when we were in a hurry - we ate at the bar in the rear and it was great!...More
We ate in the bar area and had a combination of food off both the dinner and bar menus. Food was OK; flatbreads were good. Not inexpensive. Bar atmosphere was good, but a bit on the noisy side from the entertainment, so it was a...More
make reservations, small awkward parking for patrons, but food and service was excellent. tables are somewhat close together , so it can be a bit noisy
Just went here for Mother's Day. Since I'm not a fan of seafood I got the Cavatelli with Chicken Only. It wasn't anything to write home about. It was OK, but kind of bland. I've definitely had better pasta dishes in Cape May and elsewhere....More
If you can get into the bar section of the restaurant you will find a great atmosphere and top of the line bar food. The restaurant section serves top choice meats and sea food, Excellent.