Party of 6 for dinner. Not a fan of the pizza, didn't like the sauce, and the crust was very tough like the dough is over mixed. Pasta dishes we're just okay. Server was friendly and efficient. Probably will not return.
1 - 10 of 69 reviews
Brick oven pizza at Brooklyn's is good but I'm used to a crisper crust and this seemed soggy. Probably the brick oven. Not my favorite. The place has been around for a long long time so they do have a following. Try it for yourself.
Easy off of Route 4 across from the FDU entrance Brooklyn Pizza is the best brick oven pizza around. fast service, very good food, fair price. Be warned they only take cash and there is no ATM inside so have cash. Also no more tap...More
First, this is the real deal if your are looking for authentic pizza. They used the coal fired brick oven and a recipe going back 90 years. The pizza was fantastic. This a casual atmosphere restaurant. (In fact it appears it used to be an...More
Went to lunch today at Brooklyns and was totally blown away by how fabulous it was ! Had calamari appetizer which was great and a large pie that was the highlight! There pizza is just really fabulous ! Definitely one of the best spots I...More
We were in between Lunch and Dinner and decided to give Brooklyn a try. We were not disappointed. We arrived midafternoon and the spacious parking lot was almost empty. There were only customers at one other table. We decided to try their Garlic Bread and...More
Coal fired pizza is all about the crust, and this place delivers the best crust in Bergen by far (or at least until Hoboken, where the Grimaldis have a place). But it's more than just crust. Their homemade mozzarella is special, and the sauce is...More