We found the wait staff to be excellent. The prices were reasonable and the dinners were large and plentiful.
1 - 10 of 285 reviews
Food was bland and overpriced. Save your money. If you are a seafood person this is not the place for you. You will be disappointed.
The location is not so bad and outdoor dining will be fine when the roadworks will be over The oyters are good, the softshell cranb correct but in a too heavy creamy sauce...Just at the pan with a little butter and a slice of lemon...More
She has got me to heaven with her creator it we still enjoy visiting this formidable place. Great service and even greater food! Great portions at great prices! A must do if you are in City Island!
We live at the Jersey shore and are very particular about our seafood. The lobster house did not disappoint. Anthony our server was great. The antipasto, breads, and salad were delicious. We had dungeness and king crab. The portions were so huge we had meals...More
Very good place for lobsters , very busy , nice staff , we had the feast lobster , it was very good and plentiful, really a feast for king! Worth every penny! Will come back! Just make sure you come hungry
Sprawling. Apparently, a City Island fixture. Food is excellent. Lobster roll, steamed clams are perfect. No need for the complimentary cubed cheese/olive and soggy salad. Too much food and not great. Sit outside if not too cold or just bundle up. Inside has unfortunate stale...More
I've been to all the restaurants on CI and the Lobster House i the best in so many ways esp value. You get great food and lots of it without sacrificing quality for quantity all with courteous service and a great atmosphere. I went with...More
City island is know for the best seafood and this place certainly does not disappoint . We were greeted by a valet to park our car and once inside we were greeted by the host who led us to our table . Our waitress was...More