We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
typical tourist ice cream shop experience, nothing noteworthy. Except for one unusual offering of a mixture that I have never seen, eaten, heard of, or ever imagined: The Godfather, which is Vanilla ice cream topped with olive oil and gourmet vinegar. All I have to...say is trust your instinct, I'm sure there are some people who would eat ice cream with oil and vinegar, but if you are not sure, don't waste $8-$10 to confirm what you already suspect - it is horrible on multiple levels.
It's not even the combination that I am against, as I am a big fan of quality oil and vinegars, it is the fact that the oil is not even fresh, it's just greasy and stale tasting oil, I'm not even certain that they used extra virgin olive oil, it was just oily with no olive fragrance. There is so much stale oily taste, I can't even taste the hyped gourmet vinegar so can't comment on the vinegar.
So, i concluded that either this whole combination is just a bad idea, or that they messed it up by not using the proper oil /vinegar. In either case, $8 -$10 went straight into the trash can.More
Date of visit: May 2021
moomooscreamery, Owner at Moo Moo's Creamery, responded to this reviewResponded 1 June 2021
Hi, this isn’t a review for our ice cream shop. Never have served that flavor, never will. Please remove your review as it does not apply to my business. Thank you.
Flavors were fun, icecream was delicious, price was reasonable for home made icecream. They had a good system for orders and kept social distancing organized. I would go here again - fun to do after hiking (like at the foundry preserve nearby)
Covid changes haven’t affected the quality of the ice cream. You now shout you order to the attendants from the porch and the menu board is on the floor inside ... but they seem to handle things well from a Covid perspective e and the...ice cream is very good. I tried the maple bourbon flavor and my daughter had vanilla with some toppings. A single with two toppings and a double scoop was $12.50... which now that I think of it seems a bit high.More
I am a BIG TIME, PIG TIME ice cream fanatic. And this is the best ice cream I have had thus far. Maybe it's a stretch but its my favorite. Perhaps its tied with Van Leewans in NYC. However, I wouldn't have ANY issue coming...from NYC, taking an hour and change train ride, JUST to get this ice cream. However, its even that much more rewarding after have a nice, few hours hike at the Breakneck Ridge trail.
The flavors here are all just so....DAMN! That's all I can say. Just burst with flavor. If you get a blueberry cream ice cream, you're testing that blueberry. If you get pumpkin, you're tasting that pumpkin. You're TASTING THE ACTUAL flavors! Not no artificial fakeness. With every lick you consuming the beautiful ice cream artistry from Moo Moo's. Making love to your taste buds, sending your palette on a journey. Sometimes my stomach doesn't always react well to dairy but I ALWAYS take a chance with Moo Moo's. I can risk an ass attack.
If you are an ice cream fan, you owe it to yourself to come here!! WILL NOT be disappointed.
If its a nice day, get your ice cream and enjoy it across the street where the Hudson River dock is. Amazing views, with amazing ice cream= Euphoria.More
Ice cream made fresh daily with real cream. Lots of flavors and add-in. You can walk across the street, sit on the park bench and enjoy the view of tlHudson Bay while viewing West Point Academy across the way.
Stopped in here for a scoop after sailing on the Clearwater. The little shop was really busy and they were running out of several flavors.
The ice cream was good, but not great. At $5 for one scoop, it is among the highest prices I've...ever paid for ice cream.
The servers were doing a good job of keeping up with the traffic.More
Response from Firefly2416 | Reviewed this property |
Good evening, if you go to the website. The grill portion has prices but I didn't see a section for ice cream. Three of us ate ice cream cones almost everyday. We ordered two kids cone and a small. It was all under ten... More
Good evening, if you go to the website. The grill portion has prices but I didn't see a section for ice cream. Three of us ate ice cream cones almost everyday. We ordered two kids cone and a small. It was all under ten dollars. I know u might say, a kiddie cone and smalls? There portions are very generous. A small at Martha's is like a medium at Carvel. I hope that helps a little. Stop in. The ice cream is amazing!
Are you sure you want to delete this answer?
Is This Your Listing?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.