The atmosphere was nice and quiet in the late afternoon. Three of us had wings and the sauces were pretty good but could have hotter. The Philly was prepared and enjoyable.
1 - 10 of 202 reviews
Super nice staff, huge bar with tables and wait staff as well. A few TVs so you can watch a game if wanted. Wanted a drink and appetizers. Good beer selection including local favorites. Some unique menu items. Our favorite was the Reuben fritters. Just...More
We did not eat here, just had drinks. The bartenders were very attentive and the place is clean and has a lot of TVs.
After spending the whole day at the Baseball Hall of Fame, I was in dire need of a cool drink and a bite to eat. Headed over to this local spot. Greeted and welcomed at the bar. Tried some of the local brews. Enjoyed the...More
My wife & I have been on a quest for many years to find the very best REUBENS in NYS! Our search is over. Cooley's tavern in Cooperstown makes the the very best! We have been back to Cooley's several times to reassure ourselves that...More
Great experience in this little pub. Didn’t have time for food but the bartender was very friendly and the food he served to the person across from us, looked awesome.
We visited when there was construction on the street and would have missed it completely had other Indians fans at dinner not told us that they were going there. We had a great time here watching Game 5 of the AL Division series. Beer was...More
We visited Cooley's twice on our last visit to Cooperstown. Once on a Sunday early afternoon and again later mid week. Both times we had great service and good food. The fare is tavern food but the menu is varied with some local touches. Both...More