In town to watch my son play summer baseball with the Crush. Stopped in for lunch...pizza was awesome...cool decor...very clean. Would definitely eat here again.
1 - 10 of 65 reviews
Been hearing about Pontillo's from my wife's grandfather for years and so it just had to be my first meal on my first trip to Cortland. We had takeout from here on my first night and went again to pick it up on day three....More
We had dinner tonight for the first time. We had heard that they recently remodeled, and the place is very cute. We have ordered pizza and wings in the past for delivery, so we are familiar with their food. Pontillo's does now serve wine and...More
I moved to cortland,ny to be closer to family. I asked for a recommendation for a pizza and wings place. Pontillo's delivered! No pun intended. I ordered mild wings with extra sauce, and a large pizza and garlic knots. Awesome all the way around. Fresh!...More
Pontillo's has undergone a renovation; if you are familiar with the old look, you would hardly recognize the new look – it is sleek and modern and lovely. But the food is as good as always. Thank heavens they did not mess with the kitchen!...More
We went there for a family dinner the pizza came out was absolutely awful the wings were even worse they were burnt however I must say the atmosphere was amazing The Waitresses were great. We were not impressed with the food at all very probable...More
The pizza is good. The crust is the best part. And the service is friendly and efficient. Prices are low to average. It's just that nothing sets the place apart. It is up-state-ny pizza, not the delicious crisp think crust of New York City. Alas
The food is AMAZING, however the service was terrible. I had to get someone's attention, then waited 45 for a cold sub at a "not-so-busy" time, then when I said something they mumbled under their breath and walked away. What a shame, the sub was...More
This sandwich is delish. Just wish one could have a small salad in place of the fries Love the salad dressing (Italian) and your meat balls.