Food is good, ambiance works for this area and service very good. This restaurant is deservedly one of the "in" places in East Hampton.
51 - 60 of 250 reviews
Just returned from a fabulous long weekend in the Hamptons. Our first...but not our last. Our first night we dined at Nick & Toni's which came highly recommended here on TripAdvisor. The food was just OK, definitely not worthy of the rating. Our server was...More
My last two meals here have been disappointing. I had fish dishes both times one a sea bass with heavy brown sauce and most recently the lobster pasta dish billed as lobster bolognese. It is better suited to a meat sauce. Who knew it was...More
I wanted to really love this restaurant. I had read so much about it, and had very high expectations, so perhaps that is why I was a bit disappointed. The food was good, but not fantastic. Our server forgot my husband's salad and was very...More
We've been coming to nick and Toni's for years and food is better then ever. You can't go wrong with the cocktails and wood fired fish dishes. Swordfish was excellent. Highly recommend dining here mid-week to avoid the crowds.
We have been coming out east for many years, but never went to Nick and Toni's before. We heard it was excellent- but impossible to get reservations. I guess we may have gotten lucky because on our first attempt, we got in. The food and...More
Recently renovated and refreshed, N&T has lost none of the charm that makes this a major destination year-round. The Summer Season is a bit frantic; be-prepared for it and be flexible. Much more enjoyable off-season; still busy and a scene, albeit way more manageable. Food...More
This comes as a highly recommended restaurant for a lot of reasons and I am told it is hard to get a table at short notice - our experience was a good experience. enjoyable, no complaints, good food ...... however not a stand out over...More