wanted a late night snack and saw sign for slice of pizza and pop so gave it a try. Very fast service and great pizza.
1 - 10 of 11 reviews
We have had pizza in more places than I can remember...north Jersey, Manhattan, Hilton Head...You name it. Pudgies North Main remains our favorite. There's just something about their crust. Perfect! Not just something to slab the toppings on...The crust is a big part of the...More
Local spot in Elmira that has several locations around town. Busy place that a lot of locals frequent. I had a slice of stromboli & small order of chicken wings. The stromboli was OK...pretty saucy, but lacking much meat. It had big chunks of green...More
Pudgie's doesn't make what is widely considered to be the standard New York or Chicago style pizza, but instead somewhat of a combination of the two. Lots of sauce, lots of cheese, and it's delicious.
Just found out today that a friend of mine had ordered from there and then cancelled. They then tried to force her to pay for the order to the extent they sent the cops to her house and threatened to arrest her over an $18...More
Had a family Birthday party, and ordered cheese sheet pizza. Great service, pizza was hot, and delicious! Staff is friendly and provides fast service.
While ordering pizza I mentioned that I played football with Pudgie (Charles Cleary) at EFA (hoping to get a free slice). The girl at the counter said "Listen, you are the third person this week that came in here to say that they played football...More
The food at Pudgies (Southside, not on College Ave.) is fantastic. The service is hit or miss. Sometimes you are warmly greeted, but if the little mean Italian owner is working, watch out! That lady is horrible, mean and provides the worst customer service I've...More