Not too many dinner choices in Hamilton, but this place is definitely a romantic spot with great atmosphere and great food.
1 - 10 of 20 reviews
Great place for a romantic dinner. Food was fantastik!!!! The Hamilton Inn is so beautiful, you will feel spoiled.
This classic New England Inn serves food that is innovative and resonably priced. I had a gnocchi with dried carrot chips that was very intriguing. My son had a delicious pork tenderloin, with a sweet/savory maple sauce and a piece of crisply cooked speck. Very...More
We've dined here two times before and had very good meals and experiences. This time, portion sizes were minuscule. $35 for a cod entree contained tiny piece of fish, 3 halves of a baby potato and sauce. The dollop of greens on the plate was...More
This restaurant is widely agreed on as the best option for fine dining in the Hamilton area. For a nice dinner (frequented by visiting Colgate parents) this is a great choice. Often compared to the Colgate Inn, the Hamilton Inn offers a slightly finer dining...More
Spent the night in this wonderful quaint country inn. Wonderful room. Be sure to try to get room #2. Two room suite with private in room bath. Only five rooms at the inn, so you need to call well in advance in the summer. Check...More
Good specials and menu has lots to choose from. Well-prepared dinners and bartending was fine. In cool/cold weather, nice fire in fireplace.
I came here every week when I went to Colgate! I just graduated and this really was the only fine dining restaurant within 20 miles of the university. The manager is the greatest guy in the world and Zachariah always does a great job waiting...More
Hadn't been back to the Hamilton Inn since our first visit years ago. Pretty much as I had remembered it. The food was good, and the service was fine. We appreciated the fact that the manager also came around a couple times to ask if...More
The Hamilton Inn has held forth in a roomy old remodeled farmhouse for over 25 years now, and for many years it was our favorite in the Hamilton area. A few years ago the former owner closed the place down for a time; Colgate University...More
Dear Itinerant_scholar, Thank you for your review of the Hamilton Inn. I am sorry to hear that your recent experience was not what you had hoped for. Of course we strive to treat each of our guests to a special and memorable experience with warm,...More