My Uncle Don wanted to take us here for lunch after getting gas on the reservation. It had accessible parking for our camper. I had a hard time choosing what to order as there were so many great choices. Portions were great and the desserts...were over the top. Will have to come back again when we are back in the area.More

We were near Sunset Bay actually looking for a coffee Cafe and drove by Aunt Millie's. I have heard great things about this place so we turned around and decided to try it out. We walked in and holy huge desserts !!! The cinnamon rolls...and pastry hearts are bigger than my head...no lie.... We were sat at a booth and Cara was our server. She was very nice and she was efficient as well. My cousin opted for the turkey salad sandwich with soup special and I had the chicken finger melt. Both sandwiches were delicious and filling but I couldn't stop eyeing up the desserts lol. I was too full for dessert so I took home a piece of apple strudel which was delicious. We were told every dessert is home made and they all looked amazing I'm sorry I didn't take a picture to put with this review. Everything looked amazing do yourself a favor and stop here you won't be sorry or hungary when you leave.More

Great quick sit down breakfast spot. Heading to Niagra Falls after family time in Ohio. Friendly staff, clean, reasonably priced with a variety including decadent baked goods made on site.

We were traveling up to the Garth Brooks concert in Orchard Park NY and we wanted to get a quick bite to eat on the way. There were 6 of us together and we saw Aunt Millie's so we decided to stop. We were seated...right away, but took awhile for our server to get to us. They were pretty busy for 4:00 on a Saturday afternoon. Finally our server came and took our orders. We all had something different. I had the Taco salad, my wife had beef on wick. My Taco salad was bad, when it first came it looked good until you start eating it. The shell was really oily and soggy, the only part you could eat was around the top edges. The inside lettuce was disgusting, instead of being fresh and crisp it was mush, wilted, non eatable. I had to pick through it to find things I could eat. I ended up leaving at least half of it. My wife's Beef on wick was small and dry, she had to ask for some au jus to try and moisten it up so she could eat it. I guess everyone else we were with had a average meal. Overall, the service was slow, but good when there, the food was only fair at best. And for some reason we ever would eat there again I would not have the Taco salad for sure.More

06/09/2022 We were traveling in the south towns and I had a taste for dessert. I remembered this place in Silver Creek. So we headed for Aunt Millie’s. I was not disappointed, however I had to wait. The others in the party wanted to also...have dinner. We ate dinner here. Dinner was fine, the three of us had Turkey dinners. Once completed we had to get up and checked out the dessert cases. One will not be disappointed by the variety and the quality of the baked goods. In fact the problem you will have here is deciding what to try . My wife had a chocolate peanut butter cream pipe while my friend and I split a carrot cake. We were not disappointed! If you want great dessert and numerous choices, try this place out!More

We always look for something good, ideally local, and are often disappointed. NOT today. When we arrived, the parking lot was full, a good sign of local favorite, but how long would the wait be? We were on the road and didn't really want to...spend time waiting. The place was busy, but we only waited a couple of minutes for a table. (Which was almost sad because the amazing baked goods they had on display were incredible). Once seated, we got our drink orders immediately, and our food orders promptly after. I ordered the veggie omelet and my hubby ordered the special beef sandwich on weck, though there is a version of that on the regular menu, so you won't miss out. And here is where is gets tricky. I don't know what was better, the service or the food. The omelet was jammed with delicious veggies, the potatoes that came with the omelet were perfect, the fries that came with the sandwich, ditto, the sandwich was moist, hearty and delicious, but most of all, the rye toast that came with the omelet was over the top. Because they are a bakery, we asked if we could buy a loaf of the rye bread, but they don't currently sell it (word to Aunt Millie-sell your bread!!!) We cannot recommend Aunt Millies enough. GREAT staff, great food, great atmosphere, convenient location. Did I forget to mention affordable?More

My sister & I stopped on the way back from Orchard Park!! I had my usual tender, delicious, Liver & Onions, with red smashed potatoes, & vegetable! We both had the homemade, yummy, cabbage soup! Becky had a FAT pocket sandwich! I had a miniature...blackberry pie, & Becky got 3 scrumptious handmade desserts to go! Our waitress filled our coffee cups several times!! She was a HOOT, too! We had fun talking & teasing each other!! It was s totally awesome experience!! They serve hot, little, delightful rolls too!!More

We had dinner here last week. The food was delicious with great sized portions. Our server was terrific and extremely attentive. We did even have to ask for a refill on our drinks, she was right on it. Deserts were amazing and huge. The best...thing about this place was the value. Great price for a tremendous meal. We will definitely be back.More

Actually really did have a hot dog with some waffle fries on a beautiful day sitting outside. The prices are good the service is good and you can't go wrong going there anytime of the day they're open

My sister, I, & our neice ate here, about a week ago! I had my usual, scrumptious, liver & onions, with red skin potatoes, & salad! Becky had the Cobb salad & a huge hunk of carrot cake! Robin had the turkey dinner, with a...huge brownie tower, for dessert! We got her husband a piece of banana cream pie! We were interacting with our lovely waitress, along with a very friendly, entertaining waiter! We had a blast & delicious food!!More

During this pandemic we decided to go for a drive in our corvette. We saw a bbq and pulled in. So glad we did. The people gave us the menu to review, took our order. Very friendly and knowledgeable. Our food was cooked just the...way we ordered it. We even got ourselves some cupcakes!More

This place has been a favorite of mine for years! I love coming here for a delicious breakfast. Order a grilled cinnamon bun, won't be sad you did. You'd be sad you didn't. During COVID pandemic and no eating in and only take out, my...husband band I enjoyed an awesome chicken BBQ! Everything about it was tasty. Oh, if you leave Aunt Millie's without having it taking home dessert, you're crazy. Best carrot cake and coconut cream pie! Oh, the peanut butter pie too!!!More