We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Commander Cody's

Shelter Island New York, Shelter Island, NY
+1 631-749-1851
Website
Share
Map updates are paused. Zoom in to see updated info.
Reset zoom
Updating Map...
Overview
  • Excellent52%
  • Very good37%
  • Average2%
  • Poor4%
  • Terrible5%
Travellers talk about
“fresh seafood” (7 reviews)
“fries” (11 reviews)
Open Now
11:00 AM - 9:00 PM Hours
CUISINES
American, Seafood
PRICE
$
RATINGS
Food
Service
Value
Atmosphere
LOCATION
Shelter Island New York, Shelter Island, NY
All Details
Write a ReviewReviews (69)
Traveller rating
Traveller type
Time of year
Language

1 - 10 of 67 reviews

Reviewed 31 August 2018

Amazing. Top quality at low prices. The lunch baskets were fantastic. I had the Hake, a brilliant under rated fish which was cooked to perfection. The prawns were big and juicy. My first expereince of this type of fish market / lunch shack. Amazing -...More

Thank Robert J T
Reviewed 21 August 2018

We took some of their food out on two occasions. Quality of food was very good. I'd recommend Commander Cody's.

Thank Paul33740
Reviewed 9 August 2018 via mobile

Fresh local fish daily, backed up by a Culinary School graduate. Best shrimp cocktails, live lobster, great seafood soups, and not at all least - fried chicken like you always wanted but rarely get!

Thank Joseph M
Reviewed 19 June 2018 via mobile

Last night I ordered the fried chicken. I'd forgotten how good it was. It was so juicy and cooked perfectly. The homemade potato salad and fries were delicious. I'll be back.

Thank bperrillo
Reviewed 19 December 2017 via mobile

If you are looking for fancy, this is NOT your place! However, if you are looking for the freshest seafood, perfectly cooked, this is most definately your place. I’ve been coming here for years. It’s a different kind of joint. It’s always a trip...in a...More

Thank Darline_Gpt
Reviewed 22 October 2017 via mobile

Stopped here for lunch as recommended by a local. Very casual atmosphere. The soups were amazing. Lots of local fish, crab and clams. Off the beaten path, but worth it.

Thank Phyllis M
Reviewed 5 September 2017

The most relaxed eatery on Shelter Island - but, oh boy what food! Fresh seafood served at sensible prices. Take your own wine / beer.

Thank warmwaterdiver
Reviewed 10 July 2017

Commander Cody's is a small indoor/outdoor restaurant hidden off Smith Street. It has great food. The owner and his daughter run the place and cook themselves. Very nice people. You can eat outdoors on their picnic tables or indoors. I like the outdoors on a...More

Thank Dale S
Reviewed 24 October 2016

I've eaten here before, love the food, moderately priced, all super fresh. You might read some reviews of waiting a long time for food to be prepared, not the case in the off season. Super friendly staff, excellent food, a must for seafood lover.

Thank jon p
Reviewed 22 October 2016

Very fresh daily fish. Today's catch sold or dinners cooked for eat-in or take out. Probably the best fried chicken anywhere! Some love to eat there.....and bring your bottle of wine.

Thank islandwhine
Nearby
Nearby HotelsSee all 5 hotels in Shelter Island
Dering Harbor Inn
61 reviews
.74 km away
Shelter Island House
82 reviews
.78 km away
Sunset Beach
124 reviews
1.06 km away
The Pridwin Hotel
254 reviews
1.95 km away
Nearby Restaurants
Marie Eiffel Market
137 reviews
.64 km away
The Flying Goat Restaurant
16 reviews
.33 km away
Shelter Island Heights Pharmacy
16 reviews
.54 km away
Sunset Beach
207 reviews
1.05 km away
Nearby Attractions
Venture Out Shelter Island Paddle Board Rentals
9 reviews
1.09 km away
Antique Carousel
128 reviews
2.61 km away
Shelter Island Kayak
25 reviews
1.99 km away
Greenport Harbor Brewing Co.
77 reviews
2.78 km away
Questions & Answers
Get quick answers from Commander Cody's staff and past visitors.
Note: your question will be posted publicly on the Questions & Answers page.
Posting guidelines
Submit
Improve this listing

Restaurant Details

Rating summary
  • Food
    Service
  • Value
    Atmosphere
Cuisine
Meals
Lunch, Dinner
Restaurant features
Takeout, Outdoor Seating, Seating
Good for
Child-friendly, Kids
Open Hours
Sunday
11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Monday
11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Tuesday
11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Wednesday
11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Thursday
11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Friday
11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Saturday
11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Location and Contact Information
  • Address: Shelter Island New York, Shelter Island, NY
  • Location: United States  >  New York (NY)  >  Long Island  >  Hamptons  >  Shelter Island
  • Phone Number: +1 631-749-1851
Is This Your TripAdvisor Listing?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more. Claim Your Listing