McCarthy's food is absolutely delicious. Unique menu items. The atmosphere is perfect for an Irish Pub. The service was good. Highly recommended.
1 - 10 of 269 reviews
Stopped in early on a saturday evening - ordered corn beef and cabbage. It was not as I expected - cubes of corned beef that was chewy at best. May be fun during season but I expected more on a traditional corned beef dinner.
Food was decent enough for pub fare. Prices average. Service ok. We went without a waitress for a long time. Waited for more than ten minutes before someone got our drink order. Fish and chips is a staple for us, and theirs was only ok,...More
Visited Port Clinton during the fall (off season), & had a great dinner. Ordered the local perch & a Reuben boxty for dinner = both were delicious.
AWESOME! Thank you so much! Glad you had a great time!
Fun atmosphere for Saturday College football games. Good beer selection and the Irish themed menu is pretty good. Not really a complaint because they tasted phenomenally good, but, the kraut balls will mess you for days.....LOL
Thank you so much Tim! Cheers!
Wow we really lucked out here on Saturday night by dropping in to McCarthy's Pub. Extra Stout was rocking the House with lively sing along music and a little gal who played the fiddle second to none (the Devil came down to Georgia)! Treated to...More
Awesome! That's what I'm talking about! Cheers!
Good Irish inspired food in a comfortable environment. Good beer selection. Separate family dining room.
Hey thanks Larry! Cheers!
Love this place, friendly happy people. very informative on the jet express and things to do at Put in Bay. Sauerkraut balls delish and great drinks.
Thank you Melany! Cheers!
Nothing to rave about, but not bad. Had a decent meal. Chips and dip are ok, and so is Reuben. Staff are nice, but not overly accommodating. I'd say probably better for lunch than dinner.
Thank you for taking the time to review us! Next time we will blow your socks off! Cheers!
We have stopped here a few times. Service has always been good, friendly. Food portions are great. They feature both standard Irish fare as well as American bar food.
Awesome review! Thank you so much for taking the time to review our business!