Delicious, plentiful, home cooked meals I had chicken parm and hubby the seafood medley in pastry. Wow. Our second time here in two years. Worth the stop.
1 - 10 of 203 reviews
My husband and I decided to stop overnight In Carlisle but we’re concerned about getting a good meal......well we were not disappointed!!! Amazing food, large portions and friendly cozy atmosphere! All meals come with two sides! Don’t look anywhere else! We can’t wait to come...More
Found this by accident, but it will be our regular stop going north and south. Very friendly staff, good food, We both had steaks and they came with all the fixings. The salad was cold and the dressing fresh. It is a repeat visit.
So I really have had good experiences here at the Rustic. Last time with Prime Rib, This time with the Fettuccine. First... The young lady seating us was very pleasant,as was our server. The place was pretty busy but the staff was moving like they...More
Rustic Tavern is a great, family, restaurant; BUT, something changed, and I don’t know what Ate there last night with friends- 4 total in the party. ONE hour- we didn’t have our food. The food was good when it finally got there... but the service...More
After a day enjoying Col. Denning State Park & Lake Henrietta, we were looking for some good food in a casual setting. While the Rustic Tavern doesn't look special from the outside, tucked into a non-food service part of town, once inside the door the...More
Every time I go to the Rustic Tavern I am always very happy with the service we get. But on this particular day my family and I had GREAT tasting food and GREAT service even though they were busy. When I go i always go...More
Not what I expected pulling into the parking lot adjacent to an auto dealer and storage spaces but looks are deceiving. Inside the restaurant, the atmosphere, casual, dimly lit over tables, sounds filled with conversation and jeers from the bar area watching sports. Our waitress,...More