We loved it. We weren't sure about it when we pulled up but the food and service was great. We started with mushrooms in rosemary cream sauce then had the salmon and crab cakes. All of it was great. Be aware that it is BYOB...More
1 - 10 of 49 reviews
Some of the best prepared food we have had in all the years we've been visiting our son and family in Erie.
Especially special....for some.reason my review didn't give Pie in the Sky all EXCELLENT grades....every single aspect of "Pie" is tops....please note this if you read our reviews....I have found that occasionally on Trip Advisor this happens....I will be more diligent before I hit "send."
We have been treating ourselves for our birthdays every January and May for 13 years to Pie in the Sky, a quaint and oh-so-personable treasure in Erie. Last night was no exception. Owners Mike and Carmen make every guest feel welcome to join in a...More
One of our favorite places to eat....for 15+ years. Consistent quality, great friendly service, have honestly never had a complaint! We seem to always order the same things because they're dishes we'd never make at home. Mushrooms in cream sauce appetizer, seasonal salad, I always...More
Want a change you will find it here and it is delightful and different in a good way. The owners are creative in cooking and decorating. Friendly in a quiet way.
I love Pie in the Sky. I have been there three times for dinner over the past two years and it doesn't disappoint no matter what I decided to eat. However, lamb dinner is especially delicious. The venue provides for a cozy intimate meal especially...More