Superb place - staff excellent, ambience happening, and food wonderful. It's pricey but you get what you pay for. Every dish around us looked great and we both loved every part of ours....

The tastiest natural oysters in Sydney!! Followed by a fish curry that was so delicious!! Family members had fish and chips and deep fried snapper. All meals were top quality!

Been coming here for years. Always a trusted local. Precautions implemented due to Covid (temperature check, hand sanitising stations etc) are comforting. Feel safe dining with them and the food and service is just as top notch as it’s always been. Thank you for making...us feel safe. Make sure to book ahead as they have limited space still and no byo except Tuesday’s - locals night. Will see you soon!More

Superb. Hidden gem in crows nest. Staff were superb. Highly attentive, fast service. Great eye contact and always had a smile. 3 female chefs. U rock, ladies! Food was excellent. For a seafood restaurant, my sirloin was perfect. My kid’s beef short rib dish had...a shiny bone at the end which says it all. My wife’s orange roughy was served crumbed and not grilled as ordered. No problems! Apologies all around, no fuss, a quick whisper to say the new dish is almost done, this was a Masterclass in service. Then we ordered desserts. Omg, if mains were the sky, Garfishs desserts are extraterrestrial. Pastry chef, whoever she is, take a curtsy. I love my desserts and your bomb with yuzu jelly is a true 5star dish. I pay my respects Garfish, and tonight my wife n girls go to bed full n very happy.More

For what has always been such a reliably good restaurant, sadly our last experience was not up to scratch. Firstly they have removed the ability to BYO, which came as a surprise, then more importantly the salmon we ordered as medium came out very over...cooked and rubbery. My fault for not saying anything at the time, but I was starving and ate it anyway.. haha. Yes I’ll go back, but I will be certain to remind them of the medium cooked expectation.More

We are regulars at Garfish, mostly at Crow's Nest because the food is good and the service adequate, the wine list is a bit unreasonable and so we have chosen it because of it's BYO policy. When we booked for last Saturday we were not...told they had stopped BYO and on arrival we were offered corkage of $20 per bottle. I don't mind a reasonable per head corkage but $20 per bottle is just profiteering from the unusual circumstances. We walked out in disgust.More

I've been a few times to Garfish Crows Nest and the food is good. However it's usually too noisy to converse and crowded, so the dining experience is compromised. Now in the post-COVID world I visited again, with some tables removed. At this moment in...time, it's a premium experience. It ought to be since it's premium prices. Please don't make the mistake of putting the tables back in again and packing people in like sardines. You may have sardines on a menu, but customers aren't sardines. Everyone lost money in COVID, so trying to claw it all back by packing people in will mean a bigger loss in the long term. Sell off those old extra tables and chairs, and protect the dining experience. You've discovered the formula - don't blow it.More