The reviewers are right. This is the best ice cream on the island. Made in store with a great selection of amazing flavors. Fresh,creamy, and delicious. The staff is plrasaant and confident you are going to enjoy.
1 - 10 of 2,635 reviews
Although we only tasted a few varieties of their offerings all of thew were delicious! Best ice cream we ever had!
We come down to Chincoteague for a week at a time several times a year every year to visit relatives who live here. Island Creamy is a must stop for us, every night of every trip, no matter what. If we're on the island for...More
you can't go to Chincoteague without going here! Best ice cream ever! Always has a line out the door (even in December) but worth it. Line moves right along too
Bourbon salted Carmel and java jolt deliciousness! I absolutely love there home made ice cream! We also stopped in the morning to get coffee to take with us to the beach, it was 24 degrees and sunny. The staff is very welcomed,friendly and always have...More