First time to Madeline Island. We ordered the meat lovers pizza- highly recommend! And of course the ice cream was great too!
1 - 10 of 113 reviews
Stopped here for supper. My sister and i had the Italian sub it was hot sandwich and added fries was excellent. My husband had chicken alfredo pizza he said had excellent flavor and my son had meat lovers pizza he said it was also good....More
We stopped here recently for lunch on a very nice summer day. The attraction was the deck which gives a view of the area around the ferry boat dock and a few businesses. The main entrance area is slightly confusing. You have two cashier's area...More
Casual atmosphere but good food. Wraps, pizza & sandwiches....and ice cream! Outdoor seating available.
Decided to stay longer on the island and have dinner and was very happy with our choice. My husband specifically asked me to write a great review of the garlic burger which he states was one of the most unique ones he has every had...More
Close to ferry landing and good choice of sandwiches and ice cream. If it's not too windy (umbrellas really do take flight!) sit upstairs outside on the deck.
This place is amazing. You need to go. The food was awesome. It was a lovely day to sit outside and eat. The staff was friendly.
We were at Grampa Tony's 3 times during our stay on the island! the ice cream was awesome! Then pizza for supper. We brought it back to our campsite, and when we turned our backs, a raccoon ate it! So, back to town for another...More
There are teenagers everywhere in this shop, but they were able to handle to work (mostly) and were courteous. The food is decent for what it is and where it is...nothing gourmet or fancy. The prices were high, but I suppose it IS an island....More