We had one of the best hamburgers at Preston's steakhouse for lunch. The service was great and friendly. It is locally owned and operated. We enjoyed the great lunch before our hike in Big South Fork National Park.
1 - 10 of 45 reviews
My group of 18 enjoyed a great dinner here. My steak was juicy, tender and cooked just as ordered. The staff was extremely friendly and pleasant and took care of our large group with great hospitality despite so many separate checks.
Read the reviews and thought we would get good food or service. Well we got both and it definitely had potential for disaster as our waitress left- her shift was done and our table transitioned to another server. She picked it right up and didn't...More
You'd think a steakhouse would be pretty good. However, prices were very high for small portions, steak was tough, burgers were lacking, potato skins were literally so small that it was like a potato chip. They did have fresh potato chips which were good and...More
We have been here many times. Preston's has a great menu. The food is usually good and service varies. That is why "uneven" is the title. We ate there Saturday night and the food was good for everyone at the table (6 of us). The...More
Stopped here twice for dinner on our 4 day trip to Oneida. Had a tasty bacon cheeseburger first visit and NY strip on the second. The NY strip was cooked a prefect medium and well seasoned. The Arnold Palmer was one of the best and...More
Great place to eat, most of the time. can be a little inconsistent and sometimes takes a long time. Overall great place to eat. When every thing is right...its great. Love the Friday fish when its not over done.
Had one of the best ribeyes around. Superbly cooked and quick wait staff. Good salad bar, warm rolls with delicious baked potato and steak. Also had fried pickles and fried mushrooms. Way too much to eat. Hubby and I for sure could have shared that...More