We stopped off here after doing a lot of shopping and walking for a couple of drinks, the bar wasn’t very busy but it was just after 12 midday. The Barman was helpful, toilets weren’t very clean considering the time of day.

We stopped in for drinks during a snowy day. The staff was friendly the environment was upscale chic. We did not have any food however the entree served looked good from the other table.

We ate burgers for lunch. I think they were understaffed, as service was slow. But the food was quite good and reasonably priced. The pretzel appetizer was especially great!

My daughter and I went to Red 58 on 10/14/17 to kill some time before a Central Park Carriage Ride. My daughter had a place in mind and as we walked down the street, I pointed it out and said let's try this place. We...More

This place is wonderful. Small outdoor seating, fantastic bar & bartenders and dining seating inside. Menu is on point. I love the crab cake sliders, Tuna salad, fried calamari and the wedge.

Stopped in during Happy Hour one rainy afternoon. Good music, friendly bartender. Excellent Manhattan drink mixing. Very cozy small bar vibe.

Having completed a 2hr bike ride around Central Park we were in need of refreshments. This bar was a little gem just across the street from bike rental shop. Great service, good homemade food, average prices & "normal size food portions" just what we needed!!

Not in my opinion worth a visit. It was small and smelly! We went in because it was raining and needed to dry out I think if it had of been dry we would have walked straight out. Not a great beer selection either.

We were looking for a later meal idea and this place was recommended by our hotel. The burgers were great, as was the service. We liked this place - it's a smaller place on 58th (hence the name!) and very cozy.

Pros Dark, intimate, relaxing Well made cocktails Una the barkeeper was great fun Charming ambience Cons Hangover