I ran in and out before I could get too greedy. Got a red velvet cheesecake about the size of a large muffin. Very rich but had a great smooth texture and not overly sweet m. Overall very good.
1 - 10 of 97 reviews
Lots of cupcakes, cakes and other sweet treats. Some of the stuff is pretty good, some are mediocre. The salted caramel cupcakes are pretty good. My favorite is the red velvet. Pretty good cheesecakes as well. The lemon bars I had high hopes for, but...More
Long hike back from touristy stuff to our hotel and on the way was this wonderful little neighborhood cupcakery that called to me with S'mores cupcakes and cool AC. That's all it took. I would suspect this is one of the best bakeries in all...More
Really enjoyed our delicious treats. Walking distance from Midtown. Had the brownie with Walnuts. Very large, enough to share. Daughter got the Pudding cup which was also enough to share. Definitely worth the trip there.
Nice place to drop in on a cold March night for a post-dinner snickerdoodle. Better desserts than you can get at most of the restaurants near Times Square!
We bought 3 cupcakes to take back to our hotel room for an evening treat. We trudged through the cold wind and slush both ways and got back to our hotel to find that we had been sold 3 stale cupcakes. We went back the...More
Stopped in to order a Hummingbird cake and the young lady behind the counter was pleasant and helpful, as always. However, the young man was short, a polar opposite from her. He just seemed to be in an unhappy mood. Never have had an experience...More
I'm a long time customer and ordered my daughters birthday cake from Buttercup. I ordered it online a week before and the store was CLOSED when I went to pick it up at my designated time. The website states that they are open @ 11am...More
We stopped in after dinner on Friday night. The two guys working were extremely friendly and personable. The cupcakes and cakes were delicious, and my wife says it was the best rice krispy treat she's ever had. My only negative comment was when I went...More