Ordered Elk and Buffalo burgers for us. Both were great. Fries were tasty. Yes, it is made to order, so you have a expect a wait when they are busy. But it is well worth the wait.
1 - 10 of 430 reviews
I'm wasn't a fan of the fries but the burgers were above average. You could definitely tell they were fresh. I don't mind a wait knowing it's being prepped and cooked after I pay. How long would it take you to cook a burger? Anyways,...More
There was a line out of the door, but we waited anyway.... and so glad we did!! We had burgers that were very good... like an improved 5 Guys. I had the fried mac n cheese bites (which I'm currently craving).... and my daughter had...More
We were lucky to have fast service as i've heard the lines can get long. The buffalo burger was great and I would like to try the Elk next time.
I understand their posted sign that "All orders are cooked fresh" and "wait times can be 20 mins or longer at peak times". But hey! It's peak tourist time in the summer in Estes Park....how about PLANNING better? If it is so busy, then if...More
This was my first time I have eaten at Penelope's. It was a very good burger and fries were hot. My friend ordered the pastrami sandwich which was also delicious. It does take awhile for the food. That is why I gave this four stars....More
This is a cute place with a "walk up", order and sit down style. I ordered the "world famous" hamburger with pepper jack, bacon and o-rings. The lettuce, onions, tomatoes and pickles were fresh and plentiful. Condiments are self serve along with the drinks. The...More
I had the elk burger, delicious! Wife had the turkey burger, delicious! Have a picky son, ordered the wings with a sauce he didn't like, not their fault. They cooked a order of chicken strips for him free. Thanks! I would recommend this place.