We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows:
Internet Explorer
,
Mozilla Firefox
,
Google Chrome
. Mac:
Safari
.
Put in Bay
Put in Bay Tourism
Put in Bay Hotels
Put in Bay Bed and Breakfast
Put in Bay Holiday Rentals
Put in Bay Packages
Flights to Put in Bay
Put in Bay Restaurants
Put in Bay Attractions
Put in Bay Travel Forum
Put in Bay Pictures
Put in Bay Map
Put in Bay Guide
All Put in Bay Hotels
Put in Bay Hotel Deals
Last Minute Hotels in Put in Bay
By Hotel Type
Put in Bay Motels
Put in Bay Resorts
Family Hotels in Put in Bay
Romantic Hotels in Put in Bay
Put in Bay Beach Hotels
By Hotel Class
5-stars Hotels in Put in Bay
3-stars Hotels in Put in Bay
Popular Amenities
Put in Bay Hotels with a Pool
Pet Friendly Hotels in Put in Bay
Popular Put in Bay Categories
Hotels with Complimentary Breakfast in Put in Bay
Adults Only and Adult Friendly Hotels in Put in Bay
Put in Bay Hotels With Indoor Pools
Hotels with Kitchenette in Put in Bay
Suite Hotels Put in Bay
Family Resorts Put in Bay
Hotels with Balconies in Put in Bay
Charming Hotels in Put in Bay
Put in Bay Hotels with Smoking Rooms
Hotels with Shuttle in Put in Bay
Near Landmarks
Hotels near Perry's Victory & International Peace Memorial
Hotels near South Bass Island
Hotels near Perry's Cave
Hotels near Butterfly House
Hotels near South Bass Island Lighthouse
Hotels near Chocolate Museum
Hotels near Miller Ferry
Hotels near Lake Erie Islands Historical Society
Hotels near Stonehenge Estate
Hotels near Scheeff East Point Preserve
All Put in Bay Restaurants
Popular Types of Food
American Restaurants for Large Groups in Put in Bay
American Restaurants for Lunch in Put in Bay
BBQ Restaurants in Put in Bay
Cafés in Put in Bay
Fast Food Restaurants in Put in Bay
German Restaurants in Put in Bay
Gluten Free Restaurants in Put in Bay
Mexican Restaurants in Put in Bay
Pizza in Put in Bay
Seafood Restaurants for Large Groups in Put in Bay
Seafood Restaurants in Put in Bay
Vegan Restaurants in Put in Bay
Vegetarian Restaurants in Put in Bay
Popular Dishes
Best Risotto in Put in Bay
Best Chicken Parmesan in Put in Bay
Best Tater tots in Put in Bay
Best Nachos in Put in Bay
Best Chili in Put in Bay
Best Tacos in Put in Bay
Best Tortillas in Put in Bay
Best Reuben sandwich in Put in Bay
Best Mussels in Put in Bay
Best Crepes in Put in Bay
Best Chowder in Put in Bay
Best Burritos in Put in Bay
Best Prosciutto in Put in Bay
Best Jambalaya in Put in Bay
Best Shrimp in Put in Bay
Popular Restaurant Categories
Breakfast Restaurants in Put in Bay
Lunch Restaurants in Put in Bay
Dinner Restaurants in Put in Bay
Bakeries in Put in Bay
Desserts in Put in Bay
Kid Friendly Restaurants in Put in Bay
Late Night Restaurants in Put in Bay
Restaurants with Outdoor Seating in Put in Bay
Near Hotels
Restaurants near Put-in-Bay Condos
Restaurants near The Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel
Restaurants near Bay Lodging Resort
Restaurants near BayShore Resort
Restaurants near Park Hotel
Restaurants near Put-in-Bay Resort Hotel and Conference Center
Restaurants near Edgewater Hotel
Restaurants near Commodore Resort
Near Landmarks
Restaurants near Perry's Victory & International Peace Memorial
Restaurants near South Bass Island
Restaurants near Miller Ferry
Restaurants near Butterfly House
Restaurants near South Bass Island Lighthouse
Restaurants near Lake Erie Islands Historical Society
Restaurants near Perry's Cave
Restaurants near DeRivera Park
Restaurants near Chocolate Museum
Restaurants near Stonehenge Estate
Skip to main content
Review
Trips
Alerts
Sign in
Basket
Inbox
See all
Sign in
to get trip updates and message other travellers.
Put in Bay
Hotels
Things to do
Restaurants
Flights
Holiday Rentals
Travel Stories
Cruises
Car Hire
Tours
Add a Place
Travel Forum
Airlines
Travellers' Choice
Help Centre
Package Holidays
Best Restaurants in Put in Bay, OH
United States
Ohio (OH)
Put in Bay
Put in Bay Restaurants
Search
Restaurants in Put in Bay
View map
Also show
Hotels
Attractions
Also show
Map
Satellite
Map updates are paused. Zoom in to see updated info.
Reset zoom
Updating Map...
Return to Map
Sort by:
Highest Rating
You are zoomed out too far to see location pins. Please zoom back in.
Looking to expand your search outside of Put in Bay? We have suggestions.
Expand your search.
Looking to expand your search outside of Put in Bay? We have suggestions.
Expand your search.
1. The Forge
323 reviews
Closed Now
American
$$ - $$$
Menu
“Truffle
fries
and awesome crepes”
“
Anniversary Dinner
”
2. Goat, Soup and Whiskey
566 reviews
Closed Now
$$ - $$$
“Wife had the Creole Shrimp
pasta
& I had the New York strip with blue cheese...”
“Fabulous food… obnoxiously noisy”
3. Pasquales Cafe
394 reviews
Closed Now
American, Cafe
$$ - $$$
Menu
“Currently Quick service orders but worth...”
“Breakfast”
4. The Keys
379 reviews
Open Now
American, Caribbean
$$ - $$$
Menu
“... some other places and this restaurant set the
bar
...can't ask for much more.”
“
Conch fritters
were a yummy appetizer, Fried Shrimp plate was mostly French f...”
5. Hooligans
321 reviews
Closed today
Irish, Bar
$$ - $$$
“Others in our party had a Reuben, Buffalo Chicken
Salad
and Meatloaf dinner.”
“He loved the
burger
and wondered if all of PIB places knew the secret to good...”
6. The Boardwalk
472 reviews
Closed Now
American, Bar
$$ - $$$
Menu
“Great
Lobster Bisque
”
“Best
lobster
bisque!”
7. Upper Deck Restaurant
451 reviews
Closed Now
American, Bar
$$ - $$$
“We were urged to get the lobster
bisque
here while in Put in Bay, so we made...”
“Don't miss the
lobster bisque
.”
8. Reel Bar
212 reviews
Closed Now
American, Bar
$$ - $$$
Menu
“... homemade tater
tots
with queso were...”
“Great burgers and
beer
selection.”
9. Mossbacks Island Bar & Grill
266 reviews
Closed Now
American, Bar
$$ - $$$
Menu
“BEST PERCH & WALLEYE”
“Great food”
10. Topsy Turvey's
206 reviews
Closed Now
American, Bar
$$ - $$$
Menu
“Try the
Perch
Sandwich!”
“... This is an excellent place to grab a quick coffee and
breakfast sandwich
.”
11. Mojito Bay Tiki Bar
276 reviews
Closed Now
$$ - $$$
“Good vibe”
“Frankie and Ranke”
12. Blu Luna Ristorante Italiano
263 reviews
Closed Now
Italian
$$ - $$$
“Great lunch”
“Awesome Lasagna”
13. Round House Bar
166 reviews
Closed Now
American, Pub
$$ - $$$
“Fun day.”
“This place will kick your butt!![in a...”
14. Frosty Bar Incorporated
354 reviews
Closed Now
American, Bar
$$ - $$$
“Cheap drinks, good food,
fun atmosphere
”
“My boyfriend had the
Bloody Mary
, which was spicy and I had the Island mimosa...”
15. Put-in-Bay Brewery & Distillery
209 reviews
Closed Now
American, Bar
$$ - $$$
Menu
“Good beer”
“Good, Friendly Place to Get a Drink”
16. The Boathouse Bar and Grill
243 reviews
Closed Now
American, Bar
$$ - $$$
“Loved the fresh
Walleye
”
“The
fries
are crispy and the burgers we...”
17. Candy Bar
108 reviews
Closed Now
Dessert
$
“Chocolates are yummy!”
“Store made candy”
18. The Boardwalk Restaurant Put-In-Bay
52 reviews
Closed Now
American, Seafood
$$ - $$$
Menu
“Great
Walleye
and Perch”
“Whenever on the island, I make a point of stopping her for the
lobster bisque
...”
19. Beer Barrel Restaurant
147 reviews
Closed Now
Bar, American
$$ - $$$
“Nice bar”
“Long bar as advertised, Good service”
20. Put In Bay Cameo Pizza
137 reviews
Closed Now
Pizza
$
Menu
“Family Vacation”
“Celebrating Mother's Day & My B-day”
21. The Chicken Patio
94 reviews
Closed Now
Barbecue
$
“Chicken BBQ yum!”
“An Island treat”
22. Joe's Bar and Restaurant
97 reviews
Closed Now
American, Bar
$
Menu
“Always great!”
“A Pit Stop”
23. The Sand Bar
30 reviews
Closed Now
American
$$ - $$$
“Cool swim up bar and pool tiki bar, cold...”
“NIce Place to have drinks and sit by the...”
24. Dairy Isle
43 reviews
Closed Now
Dessert, American
$
Menu
“Tasty food”
“Good, cool treats”
25. Mr. Ed's Bar and Grille
106 reviews
Closed Now
American, Bar
$$ - $$$
“A larger, but quality bar”
“Great Live Music All Day”
26. Biergarten PIB
20 reviews
German, Bar
$$ - $$$
Menu
“Got lucky with two bar seats”
“Loved the food”
27. Tippers Seafood & Steak House
145 reviews
Closed Now
American, Bar
$$ - $$$
“Good food, polite staff”
“Good food, problematic service.”
28. Subway
18 reviews
Closed Now
Fast food
$
Menu
“Cheapest Place to Eat on the Island”
“girls vacation”
29. Fishbowl
24 reviews
Closed Now
Bar, Seafood
$$ - $$$
“Fun bar”
“Had a great night there, so they tell me!”
30. Margaritas on the Rock
26 reviews
Closed Now
Bar, Mexican
$$ - $$$
“Served in real glasses outdoors”
“Very good drinks”
Previous
Next
1
2
Frequently Asked Questions about Put in Bay
What are the best restaurants in Put in Bay that provide takeaway?
Some of the most popular restaurants in Put in Bay that provide takeaway are:
The Forge
Goat, Soup and Whiskey
Pasquales Cafe
What are the most popular restaurants in Put in Bay?
The best restaurants in Put in Bay include:
The Forge
Goat, Soup and Whiskey
Pasquales Cafe
What are the best restaurants in Put in Bay for families with children?
Some of the best restaurants in Put in Bay for families with children include:
The Forge
Goat, Soup and Whiskey
The Keys
What are the best restaurants in Put in Bay for cheap eats?
Some of the most popular restaurants in Put in Bay for cheap eats include:
Candy Bar
Put In Bay Cameo Pizza
The Chicken Patio