We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Restaurants in Put in Bay

Filter and search through restaurants with gift card offerings.
See restaurants with gift cards
View map
Map
Satellite
Map updates are paused. Zoom in to see updated info.
Reset zoom
Establishment Type
Show more
Restaurant features
Show more
Meals
Price
Cuisine
Show more
Dishes
Show more
Dietary Restrictions
Good for
Show more
Sort by:
Highest Rating
1. The Forge
323 reviewsClosed Now
American$$ - $$$Menu
“No need for dinner, as we feasted on the sandwich and poutine later.”
“I had the breakfast crepe with the smoked salmon and dill sauce and a poached...”
2. Goat, Soup and Whiskey
554 reviewsClosed Now
$$ - $$$
“Best meal of our week's vacation!”
“Open for Dinner!”
3. Pasquales Cafe
392 reviewsClosed Now
American, Cafe$$ - $$$Menu
“His burger was juicy and well-seasoned - and they were kind enough to accommo...”
“Nice menu, plenty of options from breakfast sandwiches to eggs Benedict.”
4. Hooligans
317 reviewsClosed Now
Irish, Bar$$ - $$$
“... a drink at the bar, and liked the a...”
“... shared a Shepherds pie, which was e...”
5. The Keys
373 reviews
American, Caribbean$$ - $$$Menu
“The bar had a great selection of drinks and the food was tasty here.”
“My families favorite was the French fries.”
6. Upper Deck Restaurant
449 reviewsClosed Now
American, Bar$$ - $$$
“... the best lobster bisque in Ohio and...”
“Best burger I've had in a long time!”
7. The Boardwalk
469 reviewsClosed Now
American, Bar$$ - $$$Menu
“If you don’t want potato chips with your burger, it’s extra for a salad, frie...”
“... poutine fries, onion rings and salad.”
8. Mossbacks Island Bar & Grill
257 reviewsClosed Now
American, Bar$$ - $$$Menu
“Good food & drink!”
“Fresh & Good Meal”
9. Reel Bar
208 reviewsClosed Now
American, Bar$$ - $$$Menu
“Loved the location”
“Everything Was Tasty”
10. Topsy Turvey's
202 reviews
American, Bar$$ - $$$Menu
“The burger was great!”
“... scrambled eggs and Cuban sandwich.”
11. Mojito Bay Tiki Bar
271 reviewsOpen Now
$$ - $$$
“Really great drinks, if you can handle...”
“Sand in your toes Bar!”
12. Blu Luna Ristorante Italiano
263 reviewsClosed Now
Italian$$ - $$$
“Great lunch”
“Awesome Lasagna”
13. Round House Bar
165 reviewsOpen Now
American, Pub$$ - $$$
“This place will kick your butt!![in a...”
“Looking Forward to a Weekend”
14. Frosty Bar Incorporated
347 reviewsOpen Now
American, Bar$$ - $$$
“Miller light watered down taste and nachos were mediocre.”
“Love this bar!”
15. Put-in-Bay Brewery & Distillery
206 reviewsOpen Now
American, Bar$$ - $$$Menu
“Tasty, Affordable Pizza!”
“Best pizza!”
16. The Boathouse Bar and Grill
238 reviewsOpen Now
American, Bar$$ - $$$
“Great drinks and quiet atmosphere!”
“Loved the fresh Walleye”
17. Candy Bar
108 reviewsClosed Now
Dessert$
“Chocolates are yummy!”
“Store made candy”
18. Beer Barrel Restaurant
147 reviewsClosed Now
Bar, American$$ - $$$
“Nice bar”
“Long bar as advertised, Good service”
19. The Boardwalk Restaurant Put-In-Bay
47 reviews
American, Seafood$$ - $$$Menu
“Great Lobster Bisque”
“Delicious Lobster Bisque!”
20. Put In Bay Cameo Pizza
136 reviewsOpen Now
Pizza$Menu
“Great Pizza - Quick Delivery”
“... amazing I wanted to eat it every day some of the best pizza I have ever had”
21. The Chicken Patio
91 reviewsClosed Now
Barbecue$
“An Island treat”
“First Stop Chicken”
22. Joe's Bar and Restaurant
93 reviewsClosed Now
American, Bar$Menu
“The drinks were priced well and the bartender was so friendly.”
“... themselves, relaxing in the quiet since it is down the road from downtown.”
23. The Sand Bar
30 reviews
American$$ - $$$
“Cool swim up bar and pool tiki bar, cold...”
“NIce Place to have drinks and sit by the...”
24. Dairy Isle
43 reviewsClosed Now
Dessert, American$Menu
“Yummy french fries”
“... while we were waiting for the jet express to take us back to Sandusky Pier.”
25. Mr. Ed's Bar and Grille
106 reviewsOpen Now
American, Bar$$ - $$$
“A larger, but quality bar”
“Great Live Music All Day”
26. Biergarten PIB
19 reviews
German, Bar$$ - $$$Menu
“Great German beers.”
“Loved the food”
27. Rita's Cantina
71 reviews
Mexican, Bar$$ - $$$
“Since the bar is upstairs, we had great views of the park, the street and the...”
“Bartender was fun and friendly.”
28. Tippers Seafood & Steak House
145 reviews
American, Bar$$ - $$$
“Good food, polite staff”
“Good food, problematic service.”
29. Fishbowl
24 reviews
Bar, Seafood$$ - $$$
“Fun bar”
“Had a great night there, so they tell me!”
30. Margaritas on the Rock
26 reviews
Bar, Mexican$$ - $$$
“Bets bar and staff on the island!!! Awesome drinks and food!”
“The bartender was great, gave us lots of information and patiently answered a...”
Frequently Asked Questions about Put in Bay
Some of the most popular restaurants in Put in Bay that provide takeaway are:
The best restaurants in Put in Bay include:
Some of the best restaurants in Put in Bay for families with children include:
Some of the most popular restaurants in Put in Bay for cheap eats include:
© 2022 TripAdvisor LLC All rights reserved.
Terms of UsePrivacy and Cookies StatementSite MapHow the site works

This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in Singapore. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu.