I "think" I've narrowed our one week stay to either the Sunrise Suite at the Tree Tops Guesthouse, or one of the top floor rooms (all of the cabanas are booked) at Seaside Cabanas, OR Chila's Cabin (which I can't find too much info about).
The Sunrise Suite seems to be the best rated room at Tree Tops, and most of the great reviews about Seaside Cabanas comes from people who are staying in the cabanas (which we can't book). Prices of both of these options are about the same.
Then there is Chila's Cabin... it seems to be clean and cozy with a great view from the little deck, but I'm just not sure if it would be almost "too" quiet there. Also, if security would be an issue at all since it's sort of on its own and access right from the street?
Or am I missing another good option? I know the island is small, but we would like to be able to walk to restaurants/bars/the split in under 10 minutes, so have sort of narrowed it down to the area falling between these 3 spots.
Having a nice outdoor space to enjoy the view and be able to be on the sand by the water in a minute or less is important. TV (I know...), wifi, a fridge, and A/C, with a clean/cute space in the $100ish range, and feeling safe/secure are all on the list.
Any suggestions would be much appreciated! Thanks!