This is such a tough question because we don't know you.
The best advice is to read past threads with this very question....and there are MANY.....
We've been to both island many times. We prefer Kauai but it really depends on what you are looking for! What type of activities are you interested in?Edited: 14 April 2011, 12:44
I suggest you do some serious reading and think about what kind of traveler you are and what type of vacation you want.
Either one will be a wonderful choice. Next year, go to the other one. :)
Pick which ever island suits you the best this year, and next year visit the other.
We very much enjoy visiting our neighbor islands, and have always had a great time.....not only as visitors, but as kamaainas as well.Edited: 14 April 2011, 20:58
We love scenery of oceans and cliffs, not a beach person, or shopping etc.