My husband and I tried to come here for lunch one day but we didn't realize that they close at 2:30 and had gotten there too late!! Thankfully someone did walk out of the restaurant and let us know and also told us that the food is super delicious and it turns out they were right! We made sure to go back the next night for dinner. We did not have a reservation and I highly advise that you make one as I think we got lucky since the place was super duper packed and the wait was pretty long. We really didn't mind though as this was on our list of things to do and we had to have the Pizza. This was our second time visiting the island and we couldn't leave the island without trying the pizza. Everyone always said amazing things about their pizza. The host was super nice and took down our name and the time went by quick and we sat down. We ordered an amazing soup, MINESTRONE (def make sure you order this) it's the most delicious soup you'll ever taste in your entire life. I wish I lived close to this place so I could order it all through fall and winter too. I ordered a small MARGHERITA pizza. The pizza is one of the greatest pizza's I have ever had too. It is not greasy at all and it is thin slice but the crust is not burned so you will def enjoy it. The owner Maria is so sweet she comes around and talks to everyone to make sure they feel welcomed. This really made our experience a one of a kind and when we return to the island we will def be back and I will be sure to bring my niece and nephews as they will love it too! Oh and last but not least the Cappuccino here is better than any Cappuccino you have ever tasted in any café! It is scrumptious. I just wish I wasn't soooo hungry and had time to take pictures and document all of this deliciousness. I highly recommend Pi Pizzeria to anyone visiting the island! Go here you will not only have an amazing experience it will be a lasting memory of the greatest pizza you ever had!!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.