Wished we had found this earlier - but definitely will be back next trip. Great atmosphere and great food and service. Scallops were perfectly cooked and tender. Nice fresh veggies, short but high quality wine list. They open at 5:55 PM! Except when the time changes, then it is 6.25 PM. It had been recommended by the owner of the home that we were renting and was the best place we found in 3 years of visiting Marathon. Several people came to the door, saw the menu and left ... it's pricey but worth it for the quality. Can eat inside or out, but outside is right next to Highway 1 and smokers were outside. No reservations. First come, first served. Casual dress like the rest of the Keys. Enjoy.