We went to Gandy's after a recommendation and the smell upon arrival was fantastic. Very good selection of pies and assorted delights to fill anyone's sweet tooth cavity. We purchased a Key Lime pie of course and a peanut butter pie. As soon as we got home we plunged into the pies. My wife had the KL and I had the PB. After a couple bites we looked at each other with sad and disappointed looks. Where is the lime flavor? Where is the peanut butter flavor? Was it the baker's off day or something? What happened? So we are left trying to determine where all the positive reviews are coming from. KL and PB pie rookies perhaps? Anyway we finished the pies but did not return to Gandy's. Rusty Bellies makes the best KL and PB pies in Clearwater or anywhere else for that matter. Even Publix KL pies are a grade above. That's our story and we're sticking to it.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.