Just to be clear, my review is of the Washtenaw Avenue Mr. Pizza, as there are a couple stores.
As I live close to this store it was the first place I tried when I first moved to Ypsi. Beyond the expected pizza, calzone (called a panzeratti) and other Italian offerings, this place offers subs, hot dogs, chicken sandwiches (the grilled is particularly good), cheesy breads, drinks and desserts. I always knew the pizza was good (hand tossed crust, fresh mushroom (not canned), and other vegetables) but when a friend who lived in Chicago for 10 years came to visit and declared her pizza the 'best ' she'd ever had anywhere, that pretty much sealed it. The only items that aren't as good, in my opinion, as the rest of the menu, are the desserts. The cinnamon sticks are an exception, as they always arrive hot and fresh (and soft) and aren't too sweet if you don't use the icing that comes with them.
The value for money here is excellent, although there is a delivery fee, no matter what the amount (and an $8 minimum order). It is rare for an order to take more than 30 minutes and they are open until 3am, although you have to order by 2am for delivery. The delivery people are pretty friendly and always appreciate it when you tip them a bit better when you've asked them to deliver in dicey weather.
Over all I much prefer this over the national chains and I would recommend it to anyone.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.