First, check the menu on the Coach House New London website. Not the one on TripAdvisor. They're different. My friend and I went on a very cold Tuesday night and they weren't busy. BUT we were seated by the fireplace and we were happy. We started with two lighter fares: she had red beets with onions and; I had roasted Brussels sprouts with horseradish aioli, pine nuts and shaved parmesan. Both were delicious. I ordered short ribs, she had the crusted cod with crispy leeks. Both of us cleaned our plates. We pushed forward to apple tart and gluten free chocolate cake, both with ice cream and coffee. Both of us gave the Coach House a nine, I could easily be talked into a 10. The service, as my friend said, was attentive but not intrusive. The only thing missing that night was the extra zing of excitement you get with a busy place. But that could have been the town the night, and the weather. The relaxed warmth and comfort was also welcome. Go.