Long ago my neighbor used to tell me about his wonderful breakfasts at Benny's in Fair Lawn. I always meant to go, but never got there. Well, my friend and I meet about once a month for breakfast, and the diner just wasn't doing it for us anymore. Now we have a new go-to place!
Benny's has a list of specials each day. I had the "small" spinach-feta omelet special, with home fries, toast and coffee included. It was $6.95. The small omelet was quite large, and I wasn't able to finish it. The picture I took is poor quality, but you get the idea of the size of the portion. My eggs and potatoes came out steaming, slightly browned egg and crispy potatoes, like I like them.
Coffee was excellent- I'm a coffee snob and it was hot and fresh. My friend asked for "thick, not runny " oatmeal, and she said it was tasty and nice and thick.
We are going back soon, because there are a number of meals I want to try- the cinnamon pancakes will be first!
I wanted to mention that our server was excellent. She has been a waitress for many years, and she's a pro. The restaurant has that neighborhood comfy feeling and is very welcoming- many of the customers are regulars. A couple stores down, Benny's has a bakery ice cream shoppe.
Benny's is open for M-W breakfast and lunch until 5:30am-3pm; open for dinner on TH-Fri-Sat until 9pm; Sunday open 8am-2pm It's in a strip mall, very easy to find by the arrow and the Benny's sign!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.