Been hearing about Pontillo's from my wife's grandfather for years and so it just had to be my first meal on my first trip to Cortland. We had takeout from here on my first night and went again to pick it up on day three. Loved the pizza: the crust was awesome, the sauce was fantastic, and the cheese was legit. Had several pizzas on two occasions during our visit and when we return to Cortland, will demand a return trip(s). Never ate inside but it looked really cool when I went to pick up the pizza for meal #2. Prices were really inexpensive as well. A good solid 4 stars (as in a four star pizza joint, not four star restaurant).
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.