Our first visit to Belhurst Castle and we really wanted to enjoy Edgar's Steakhouse. It was a very nice meal and the room where we sat was on the porch. Weird lighting that was too bright. They need candles on the tables and lowered lights. This place needs lots of updating like new window treatments (or no window treatments) and fresh paint, washed windows, new chairs without rips and just a general freshening up. Nice service staff, good food and overall value is good. Put some money into the "look" and you've got a real winner! Had to tell a woman next to me whose cellphone went off 4 times during our $200 meal to silence her phone. I would recommend a note in your menu or perhaps your wait staff can ask guests to be courteous to others. This was my first full day in NY and 2 or our 3 meals we had experiences with cell phones going off inside the restaurant, taking calls,etc. Manners people!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.