We stayed here last year, and it was nice to see the new renovations! The front desk staff was very helpful, although not super warm and friendly. They didn't greet you when you came in, which I found different from last year.
The continental breakfast had a decent selection, and the staff in there was great! They offer all-day coffee, as well.
Our room was a good size, very clean, great water pressure, and a beautiful view of the water. I slept great!
I chose the Sag Harbor Inn over Baron's Cove because it was much quieter. The two hotels are right next to each other, and the vibes couldn't be more different. There is a lot of activity and loud sounds, music, etc., at Baron's Cove, whereas the Sag Harbor Inn is more low key. I will stay here again next year!!!
And yes, it is expensive, but what isn't, out in the Hamptons???More