Shelter Island is clearly a culinary wasteland. Therefore, if you want to choose a restaurant, you might as well first get drunk and then stumble into any random place. They are all equally bad. After a heated discussion with my associates, we deemed Brigantine the be the least offensive. Not sure, in hindsight, if we were right, but it did not not disappoint. The food was average at best with some weird combinations of flavors that do not necessarily work well together. I chose the shrimp tacos. Unfortunately, the shell was completely soaked and therefore gross. The seafood was doused in sauce and the fries were nicely wetted in slaw sauce. The octopus appetizer should not have had a sweet glazing and desserts seemed so mediocre that we unanimously skipped. Please trust me and don't bother. Did I mentioned it was also massively overpriced?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.