According to forum posts, a recommended itinerary for Newfoundland could span over 10 to 15 days, covering key areas like St. John's, Gros Morne National Park, the Bonavista Peninsula, and Twillingate. Travelers have suggested allocating at least 3 nights in St. John's for city exploration and nearby natural attractions.

Some travelers said that for those interested in photography and nature, places like Cape St. Mary's for birdwatching and the scenic landscapes of Gros Morne are must-visits. A boat tour in Gros Morne to view the geological formations has been highly recommended, even for those unable to hike or walk long distances.

For many users, planning and booking accommodations early is crucial as places can fill up quickly, especially in popular spots like Gros Morne and St. John's. It is also advised to book ferry crossings as soon as schedules are released, particularly if traveling with a vehicle, to ensure availability.

According to forum posts, there are two primary ferry routes for traveling to Newfoundland: one to Port aux Basques and another to Argentia. The Port aux Basques ferry operates daily with options for both day and night crossings, while the Argentia route is an overnight ferry with a sailing time of approximately 16 hours.

Travelers have called out that the choice between taking a ferry during the day or night depends largely on personal preference and the availability of cabins. Night crossings are generally preferred if cabins are available, as the accommodations can significantly enhance comfort during the longer journey.

Some users find the ferry prices reasonable, considering the operational costs involved. However, others express concern over the high costs, especially for the longer Argentia route, which is more expensive compared to the shorter Port aux Basques option.

For many users, booking in advance is essential, especially if you wish to secure a cabin on overnight routes. The cabins tend to book up quickly, leaving limited options for last-minute travelers.

According to forum posts, car rental options in St. John's can be limited, especially during peak travel times. Some travelers have noted difficulty finding available rentals and suggest booking directly with rental companies well in advance to secure a vehicle.

Travelers have called out that renting directly from airport locations might be more expensive, but can occasionally offer unexpected deals. For instance, some users found more affordable options at St. John's airport compared to off-airport sites. It's also mentioned that prepaying for the rental can ensure the reservation is honored upon arrival.

For those looking to drop off the car at a different location, such as Deer Lake, significant drop-off fees are commonly mentioned. However, some users have found reasonable pricing without extra fees for specific routes like Halifax pick-up and St. John's drop-off.

Some travelers have recommended Trinity Ecotours for sea kayaking tours, which are known for good whale sightings. Additionally, forum members have mentioned that any boat tours in the northern and eastern parts of Newfoundland typically include whale sightings if they are in the area.

According to forum posts, Witless Bay is a popular location for whale watching tours, with options like Gatheralls or O'Briens offering larger boats with amenities. For a more intimate experience, Molly’s boat tours out of Witless Bay are smaller, avoiding large crowds. Elliston also offers good opportunities to see whales, especially near puffin viewing areas.

Travelers have pointed out that while in Newfoundland, keeping an eye on local wildlife reports and asking locals can also enhance chances of whale sightings, as these majestic creatures follow baitfish and can appear in various coastal areas.

According to forum posts, Newfoundland offers distinct and diverse landscapes that are unique compared to other travel destinations. Travelers have called out the rugged beauty and the presence of fjords, cliffs, and waterfalls, often with stunning sea backdrops.

Some travelers said that Newfoundland's culture is notably distinct within North America. Forum users highlighted the warmth and friendliness of the local people, unique local music, and traditional foods as key cultural experiences that make Newfoundland special.

For many users, the opportunity to see icebergs, engage in whale watching, and visit remarkable natural sites like Gros Morne National Park and L'Anse Aux Meadows adds to Newfoundland's appeal. The province is described as a paradise for hikers and nature enthusiasts, offering some of the most beautiful trails in North America.

Travelers have called out Newfoundland’s rich history, with sites like the Viking village at L'Anse Aux Meadows and the heritage of fishing communities enhancing the travel experience. This historical depth offers travelers a chance to explore past civilizations and the early European history of North America.

According to forum posts, Gros Morne National Park offers a variety of popular activities such as hiking the Lookout Trail for panoramic views, exploring the Tablelands, and engaging in boat tours like the highly recommended Western Brook Pond tour. The park is renowned for its scenic beauty and diverse hiking trails that cater to different fitness levels.

Travelers have called out specific trails for their unique experiences; the Green Gardens Trail is notable for its descent from the Tablelands to the cliffs and beach, offering a challenging yet rewarding hike. Additionally, the Gros Morne Mountain Trail, although sometimes closed for caribou calving season, provides breathtaking views from the summit, making it a must-do for adventure seekers when open.

Forum users have highlighted the park’s efforts in environmental conservation, evident from the temporary closures of trails like the Gros Morne Summit Trail during sensitive periods to protect wildlife. This commitment enhances the natural appeal of the park and ensures the preservation of its unique ecosystem for future visitors.